top of page

Design Principles: The Secret Weapon for Better Organisation Design

  • Writer: James Allan Docherty
    James Allan Docherty
  • Oct 5, 2025
  • 3 min read

When organisations start talking about redesign, the conversation often jumps straight to structure. Who reports to whom? How many layers should we have? Should we centralise, decentralise, or build a hybrid model?


All good questions — but that’s not where design starts. Without clear design principles, every decision becomes subjective. Leaders argue from preference rather than purpose. The result is a structure that looks tidy on paper but fails to deliver in practice.


Design principles are the quiet discipline behind great organisation design. They are the rules of the game — simple, directional statements that guide trade-offs, align leaders, and ensure decisions reflect strategy rather than politics.




What Design Principles Really Do



At their best, design principles translate strategy into design intent. They act as filters for every decision — from where teams sit, to what capabilities stay central, and how work flows across boundaries. They keep design work focused on outcomes, not personalities.


Good design principles are grounded in logic and evidence. They push teams to think systematically about what will create clarity, efficiency, and long-term value. For example:


  • Keep the design simple, scalable, and efficient. Avoid complexity unless it adds real value.

  • Give each team distinct responsibilities and accountabilities. Remove duplication and clarify ownership.

  • Design for future capability needs, not today’s structures or people.

  • Shape roles around business priorities, not individuals or convenience.

  • Consolidate interfaces between teams and functions wherever possible to reduce friction and speed up decisions.

  • Balance centralisation and proximity. Consolidate delivery where scale creates advantage, keep it local where customer context matters.

  • Use outsourcing and automation strategically to optimise cost, speed, and quality.

  • Right-size teams and management layers. Use spans and layers as design guardrails, not afterthoughts.



Strong principles like these don’t prescribe the answer. They set the boundaries for good decisions.




Why Principles Matter More Than Charts



Organisation design is full of trade-offs: global versus local, scale versus specialisation, control versus agility. Without shared principles, every decision becomes a negotiation. Leaders pull in different directions, and the loudest voice usually wins.


Principles create a shared language for design. They bring objectivity into conversations that can easily become personal or political. They make trade-offs visible, explainable, and faster to resolve.


They also protect the design long after the project is complete. When new leaders join or priorities shift, the principles still stand. They preserve design intent so the organisation doesn’t drift back into old habits.




How to Create Principles That Work



Start with strategy. What is the organisation trying to achieve — scale, speed, innovation, consistency? The principles should bring that strategy to life in structural terms.


Keep the list short. Five to seven strong statements are enough. Make them practical and specific. “Empower decision-making at the right level” is far more useful than “be agile.”


Co-create them with senior leaders, not just HR. If the top team builds the principles together, they’ll use them to guide decisions rather than challenge them later.


And test them early. Apply them to a live design question — such as whether to create regional hubs or maintain local teams. If they don’t clarify the choice, they’re not strong enough.




The Hard Part — Making Them Stick



The hardest part of using principles is holding the line once decisions get tough. Leaders may try to bend them for convenience or make “just this once” exceptions. HR and Org Design professionals need to anticipate that.


The fix is discipline. Keep principles visible in every design discussion. Rank them in order of importance so everyone knows which one takes priority when two clash. And when exceptions are made, document why — so you preserve integrity and learning for next time.


The best design councils and steering groups use principles as non-negotiables. Every recommendation is tested against them before sign-off. Over time, this builds trust and consistency across the organisation.




Final Word



Design principles rarely get the spotlight, but they’re what turn organisation design from opinion into intent. They keep decision-making fair, fast, and focused on what matters.


When leaders use them well, design becomes a clear, coherent process grounded in logic, not politics. When they skip them, it turns into a tug-of-war between functions and personalities.


Organisation design will always involve trade-offs. The point of principles is not to remove them — it’s to make them deliberate. That’s the difference between rearranging boxes and designing an organisation that works.

Comments


bottom of page